dark souls II
Dark Souls II is classic Souls gameplay at its most refined, and it's easily my favorite in the series.
More than anything, this game rewards you for having a plan. if you rush into new areas recklessly, you'll find yourself overwhelmed and surrounded, but taking it slow and using all of your tools will let you carve your way through. The early game level curve is generous and upgrade materials are plentiful, which encouraged me to experiment with different approaches on repeat attempts instead of using the same gear for the entire game.
The online multiplayer is much improved from the previous games in the series as well, and it's still fairly active! Whether it's getting your co-op team to huddle up for a clutch heal or chasing down an invading rascal in PvP, this game has created so many memorable interactions for me. What other game lets you dress up as a jester and plunge down an elevator shaft to bonk another player with a cooking ladle?
There are two flavors of Dark Souls II out there—the updated Scholar of the First Sin edition on modern platforms is the one to get. The multiplayer is most active on PC, but make sure to use the Blue Acolyte mod to send cheaters packing.